Homemade & Healthy Berry Frozen Yogurt

Homemade berry frozen yogurt can be healthy and delicious. This summer treat is bursting with berry flavor and the creamy flavor everyone craves with ice cream. It's worth grabbing your ice cream maker and trying this summer favorite.

This recipe is a THM S recipe, but could easily be paired down to a fuel pull with a few minor tweaks.

Two months ago our low temperature was 28 degrees Fahrenheit. Yesterday, the temperatures soared to over 100 degrees! Talk about a temperature swing! Our bodies were just not used to the temperatures and I resorted to a dinner of my favorite berry frozen yogurt.

This page may contain affiliate links. To view my full affiliate link disclosure, click here.

Jump to:

• Ingredients
• Instructions
• Equipment
• Tips and Tricks for Frozen Yogurt
• Sweetener Options
• Healthy & Homemade Berry Frozen Yogurt

What's the difference between frozen yogurt and ice cream? I told my kids that we were going to make ice cream for dinner all day as the temperatures climbed and it was not until I got to my fridge that I realized that it wasn't possible.

What was I missing?

Heavy whipping cream!

Instead, I whipped out (see what I did there) the unsweetened Greek yogurt and cottage cheese.

With Trim Healthy Mama, full-fat cottage cheese is considered an S option whereas Low-Cat Cottage Cheese is considered an FP option. Likewise 0% Greek yogurt is considered an FP and whole milk Greek yogurt is considered an S option.

In this recipe, I'm using all S options, which still makes this frozen yogurt and not ice cream.

My kids never knew the difference! You will be making four generous servings with this recipe and it's still creamy and delicious just like ice cream!

Ingredients

It's time for the good stuff now! Let's start making our berry frozen yogurt. Let's start with the simple ingredients that you will need.

Frozen berry mix
Full-fat Greek yogurt (unsweetened)
Cottage cheese
Unsweetened almond milk
Vegetable glycerin
Vanilla extract
Stevia Extract Powder (more or less to taste)

See the recipe card for the quantities

Can you use fresh berries? Yes, the frozen berry mix is simply for convenience's sake.

Instructions

Tip - If you prefer your ice cream firmer, place it in the freezer for an additional 30 minutes after churning.

Equipment

• Measuring cups & spoons
• Mixing bowl
• Immersion blender or full-sized blender
• Ice Cream churn

You can find the entire list of baking and cooking essentials that we use in our kitchen by visiting our Amazon Storefront or Like to Know shop.

Tips and Tricks for Frozen Yogurt

• Use Greek yogurt instead of regular yogurt. Regular yogurt has added water which will make ice crystals on your frozen yogurt. It waters down the consistency and makes it less like ice cream.
• Use cottage cheese instead of all yogurt. This is another added way to make the frozen yogurt tastes more like ice cream.
• Don't skip the glycerin. Some people get weirded out by this little ingredient. There are two main reasons I include it in my ice cream recipes. The first is because it helps keep the consistency more like ice cream. The second is because it helps keep the frozen yogurt from sticking to the sides of the churn.

Sweetener Options

In order to keep this a Trim Healthy Mama recipe, we are going to use stevia for this recipe.

My favorite way to sweeten ice cream is pure stevia. Most of my recipes use Gentle Sweet as my sweetener because I find it a more friendly sweetener to use and get used to taste-wise, but in the case of ice cream and frozen yogurt, pure stevia is cost-effective and sweetens lovely.

If you are living a sugar-free lifestyle, there are many other sugar alternatives that you can use.

Is the sugar-free lifestyle intriguing to you? Maybe you need my sugar-free 5-day challenge email course!

You will get the complete 5-Day Sugar Challenge Workbook, the 5-day email course, corresponding worksheets and prompts,

FAQ

What is the difference between ice cream and frozen yogurt?

This is actually quite simple! Both ice cream and frozen yogurt use dairy but ice cream comes from cream, while frozen yogurt uses cultured milk like cottage cheese or yogurt.

Can you refreeze frozen yogurt?

Yes and not. If you would like to place left-overs in the freezer, scoop them into an airtight container and place them in the freezer. When you are ready to eat it, take it out and let it sit for at least ½ hour. Because this is a frozen yogurt, the ice crystals will be quite stronger. You will need to let it sit until it starts to melt.

However, my favorite way to preserve leftovers is to just let the frozen yogurt melt and put the melted mixture back into the freezer. Place the churn back into the freezer and whenever you are ready for leftovers you can churn it right back up!